rejected pony fic idea #209

Discord makes the mane six read Fifty Shades of Grey.

Suggested by homfrog

rejected pony fic idea #208

Ponies are actually all made out of food and candy, but Pinkie is the only one who realizes it and goes around eating everypony. Actual cannibal Pinkie Pie.

Suggested by homfrog (are you surprised?), art by Tomao-tyan

rejected pony fic idea #206

Cupcakes was actually a really long-winded set up to a grand finale joke that Pinkie and Dash were performing for a talent agent but it cut off before the punchline

Suggested by homfrog (THIS BLOG SURPRISES ME EVERY DAY), art by Zicygomar

rejected pony fic idea #202

Humans are being taken from Earth and sold to ponies as slaves. Fluttershy starts an “animal rights campaign” to free them, and the rest of the mane six reluctantly join in.

Suggested by homfrog (you have him to thank for the ideas being daily again!), art by Birdco

rejected pony fic idea #192

Everyone in ponyville was actually right about Zecora. A story about the evil enchantress Zecora trying to subtly kidnap ponies to use in her potions, salves and stews, while still trying remaining on good standings with ponyville and her friends.

Suggested by Dark Pinkie

rejected pony fic idea #189

Pinkie Pie accidentally kills a pony with her party cannon.

Suggested by Ezhik

rejected pony fic idea #188

Applejack secretly likes carrots, and when she tries to tell that to her friends, they think that she has a crush on Carrot Top, and try to set them up.

Suggested by Ezhik

rejected pony fic idea #184

Pinkie Pie becomes Discord in the future and creates a time loop.

Suggested by randomiser

rejected pony fic idea #183

Soylent Pink: a Soylent Green remake set in Equestria.

Suggested by pjdelport

rejected pony fic idea #178

[pony name here] is actually an insane human, and Equestria is just a part of their imagination.

Suggested by Ezhik, art by thelivingmachine02